To the editor,

Promises are easy when nobody has to pay for them

Campaign season is a fun time.

It is that part of the year when every problem suddenly has a simple answer, every complicated issue can be solved in one sentence, and every candidate somehow discovers that the only thing standing between residents and paradise is that they have not yet been elected.

It reminds me a lot of a fifth-grade class president election.

• Vote for me, and I will get everyone free ice cream at lunch.
• Vote for me, and recess will be three hours long.
• Vote for me, and homework will be illegal.
• Vote for me, and every Friday will be pizza day, pajama day, movie day, and somehow still an early release day.
• And of course, the big one, unlimited snow days.

Never mind that we live in Arizona. Details like weather, budgets, state law, staffing, contracts, engineering, zoning, funding sources, legal authority, and basic reality tend to get in the way of a good campaign promise.

The problem is not that candidates have ideas. They should.

The problem is that promises are made without explaining how they will be accomplished, who will pay for them, what authority actually exists, or what trade-offs will be required. That is not leadership. That is a student council speech with better graphics.

In local government, you do not get a magic wand with the oath of office. You get a budget, public meeting laws, state statutes, legal limitations, competing priorities, staff capacity issues, infrastructure needs, and six other people who all have to work through the process in public.

• You cannot just promise a grocery store into existence.
• You cannot just demand a hospital and expect one to appear by Tuesday.
• You cannot just say teen center, senior center, more or less parks,  better roads, lower taxes, more police, more firefighters, more programs, more services, and pretend nobody has to explain where the money comes from or what gets delayed to pay for it.
• You cannot fix every road, lower every tax, increase every service, hire every employee, build or not every park, stop every project, approve every popular idea, reject every unpopular one, and still claim it is reality.

That may sound great on a campaign post, but it is not how government works.

Responsible leadership means telling people the truth, even when the truth is less exciting than free ice cream. It means explaining what the city can control, what the state controls, what private property owners control, what developers decide, what voters approved, and what taxpayers are actually willing to fund.

Anyone can say, “I will fix it.”

The harder question is, how?

• With what money?
• Under what legal authority?
• With whose vote?
• By what timeline?
• And what are you willing to cut, delay, raise, or change to make it happen?

Those are the questions that separate serious leadership from campaign theater.

Residents deserve more than slogans. They deserve honesty. They deserve candidates who understand the job before promising to reinvent it. They deserve people willing to do the work after the applause ends and after the campaign signs come down.

That is what I have tried to do. I have been available, responsive, hardworking, and honest with residents, even when the answer is not the easiest one to give. I do not believe in promising everything to everyone just to win an election. I believe in showing up, answering questions, doing the work, and telling people the truth.

So yes, vote for me, not because I am promising free ice cream, unlimited snow days, instant teen centers, instant hospitals, and a senior center paid for with imaginary money, but because I have been a consistent, trustworthy voice for Maricopa residents and I will keep working hard for this community.

Because at the end of the day, fifth grade campaign promises are cute when the stakes are ice cream and snow days.

They are a lot less cute when they involve roads, public safety, taxes, jobs, housing, small businesses, teen services, senior services, and the future of a growing city.

Vincent Manfredi owns InMaricopa and this is a letter written to the editor. 

Submit you letter to the editor to [email protected].